By Vincenzo Turcotte, Shop Tech Support · Updated November 15, 2026
The 50 percent rule
If the repair costs less than half of what a comparable replacement would cost, and the device still does what you need, repairing usually makes sense. Above half, start looking at replacing, especially if the device is more than five years old.
Almost always worth repairing
- Cracked phone screens on phones less than about four years old.
- Batteries that drain fast or make the phone shut off early. A new battery is cheap and makes an older phone feel new.
- Slow PCs with an old hard drive. Swapping in an SSD is one of the best upgrades there is.
- Viruses and software problems. The hardware is fine; the fix is labor.
- Overheating and loud fans. Usually dust and old thermal paste.
Signs it's time to replace
- The device no longer gets security updates (for example, phones past their update window, or a PC that can't run a supported Windows).
- Liquid damage on the main board of an older device.
- Several things failing at once.
- It can't run the apps you need, even after cleanup.
The cheapest way to find out
Get a diagnosis before deciding. Mine are free, and you get a flat quote before any work, so you can compare it with the price of a new device.
Rather have it done for you?
Free diagnostic, flat quote before any work, 90-day warranty. Plainfield and within 50 miles, or remote.